Wait...
Search Global Export Import Trade Data
Recent Searches: No Recent Searches

Adanis challenge MoEF fine for environmental violations.


Date: 19-11-2013
Subject: Adanis challenge MoEF fine for environmental violations
NEW DELHI: Adani Ports and SEZ has challenged the environment ministry's decision to impose penalties on it for environmental violations, setting the stage for a faceoff between the government and the company, possibly even a legal battle.

In a letter to the ministry dated October 14, a copy of which has been viewed by ET, APSEZ has challenged each of the seven penalties, saying the conditions have been either complied with or are not applicable to the company.

The ministry had derived these penalties from the report of a committee, headed by environmentalist Sunita Narain, set up to probe persistent complaints of environmental violations at the Adani port, power plant and SEZ complex at Mundra in Gujarat. The report, submitted in April, found that APSEZ had committed serious environmental violations.

The issue could impact the Adani Group's plans to build Australia's largest coal mine and port complex. Earlier this month, a Guardian report said the Australian government, in the aftermath of the Narain Committee report, has sought documents related to Adani's Indian violations.

Among other things, the Narain Committee said the company had hidden the true nature of its projects to obtain faster clearances. It had, for instance, delinked the port and SEZ components. It had avoided public hearings "on one pretext or another". It said the company might have even "started work prior to receiving environmental clearance".

In its final recommendations, the committee suggested, among other things, that the environment clearance (EC) for North Port — one of the port expansion projects — be scrapped. It also suggested the company set up an environmental restoration fund with a corpus of Rs 200 crore or 1% of the project cost, whichever is higher.

The ministry then invited responses from the company, after which it imposed a set of penalties, more or less based on the Narain Committee's recommendations. The Adani letter, written by APSEZ head-environment PN Roy Chowdhury, says: "There is no noncompliance or violation of the terms of the (EC)...by us". On the fund, it says: "We, therefore, respectfully request the ministry to reconsider the setup of the environment restoration fund for an amount of Rs 200 crore, which has been subjectively arrived at," adding that it was open to a development fund of "any substantially reduced amount".

In its response, the company asserts that all these representations had been made to the ministry. "No reasons have been disclosed for accepting the recommendations of the committee and also the grounds on which our response has not been accepted," the letter says.

Agrees Supreme Court lawyer Shyam Divan, who has written a book on environmental law and policy in India. "Given that they are subject to a higher appellate authority, all government decisions have to be reasoned. This helps the court or tribunal understand the process through which an order was arrived at," he said. Neither the company nor environment minister Jayanthi Natarajan responded to ET's questionnaires.

According to Ahmedabad-based lawyer Anand Yagnik, who has been arguing cases against APSEZ, the ministry could ask the company to present its case before the Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC), an advisory body of experts that advises the ministry on environmental clearances for projects. Based on what the EAC suggests, he adds, the ministry could take a final call.

One criticism of the Narain Committee report was that the penalties it recommended were small compared to the scale of environmental violations committed. The Environment Protection Act and the Environment Impact Assessment Notification empower the ministry to start criminal prosecution and to cancel environmental clearances if a company violates the conditions under which an EC has been granted.

Source : economictimes.indiatimes.com​

Get Sample Now

Which service(s) are you interested in?
 Export Data
 Import Data
 Both
 Buyers
 Suppliers
 Both
OR
 Exim Help
+


What is New?

Date: 28-02-2025
Notification No. 12/2025-CUSTOMS (N.T.)
Fixation of Tariff Value of Edible Oils, Brass Scrap, Areca Nut, Gold and Silver- Reg.

Date: 14-02-2025
Notification No. 10/2025-CUSTOMS (N.T.)
Fixation of Tariff Value of Edible Oils, Brass Scrap, Areca Nut, Gold and Silver- Reg.

Date: 13-02-2025
Notification No. 14/2025-Customs
Seeks to amend Notification 11/2021-Customs dated 01.02.2021 to amend AIDC rate on Bourbon whiskey

Date: 11-02-2025
NOTIFICATION No. 09/2025–Central Tax
Seeks to bring rules 2, 8, 24, 27, 32, 37, 38 of the CGST (Amendment) Rules, 2024 in to force

Date: 03-02-2025
[F. No. CBIC-190354/236/2021-TRU]
Corrigendum to Notification No. 50 of 2024 Customs, dated the 30th December, 2024.

Date: 01-02-2025
Notification No. 13/2025-Customs
Seeks to further amend notification No. 153/94-Customs dated the 13 th July, 1994.

Date: 01-02-2025
Notification No. 12/2025-Customs
Seeks to further amend notification No. 19/2019 dated 06 th July 2019.

Date: 01-02-2025
Notification No. 11/2025 – Customs
Seeks to further amend notification No. 25/2002-Customs, dated the 1st March, 2002 so as to add capital goods to the already existing list of capital goods exempted from basic customs duty for manufacture of lithium-ion battery of mobile phones and electrically operated vehicles.

Date: 01-02-2025
Notification No. 09/2025-Customs
Seeks to further amend notification No. 16/2017-Customs, dated the 20 th April, 2017 so to exempt certain drugs for supply under Patient Assistance Programme run by specified pharmaceutical companies.

Date: 01-02-2025
Notification No. 07/2025-Customs
Seeks to further amend notification No. 11/2018-Customs dated 02 th February, 2018 so as to exempt specified goods from the whole of levy of Social Welfare Surcharge.



Exim Guru Copyright © 1999-2025 Exim Guru. All Rights Reserved.
The information presented on the site is believed to be accurate. However, InfodriveIndia takes no legal responsibilities for the validity of the information.
Please read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy before you use this Export Import Data Directory.

EximGuru.com

C/o InfodriveIndia Pvt Ltd
F-19, Pocket F, Okhla Phase-I
Okhla Industrial Area
New Delhi - 110020, India
Phone : 011 - 40703001